How i Died S3 E09: Murder!

Play episode

Crowley has good news and bad news for Jon. And a few bodies in a study at a nearby murder mystery dinner gone wrong. 

How i Died is an Audiohm Media original, starring Vince Dajani as Jon Spacer; Shaina Waring as Sheriff Fran Crowley; David Dixon as Curtis; Caitlin Roberts as Amelia; Vyn Vox as Dr. Kim. Guest starring Daniel J. McLean as Mustard, Chris-Harris Beechy as Plum, Kyleigh Zimmerer as White, and ̶̙̿j̵̛̩o̷̢̅y̵̛͙ as ̶̙̿j̵̛̩o̷̢̅y̵̛͙.

Support the show and get bonus content at https://Patreon.com/HowiDied

Written and created by Vince Dajani. Directed by Chroma Sikora with layout from Chris Harris-Beechy and sound design by Eric Emma. Mastering by Eric Howell.

The How I Died theme song was created by Mike Lynch at SilentMikeMusic.com.

Show notes and transcript available at https://audiohmmedia.com/howidied/

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript: How i Died S3 E09: Murder!

This transcript is adapted from the episode’s original script, so the final audio may differ slightly.

INT. JJ'S DINER – NIGHT

[Patrons are eating, talking and ordering. Dishes clang. Crowley takes a bite.]

Crowley: (food in her mouth) You gonna eat dinner?

[Jon shifts.]

Jon: How can you be hungry at a time like this?

[Crowley adjusts, looking at her watch.]

Crowley: 7:45?

Jon: You know what I mean.

[Crowley puts down her silverware.]

Crowley: Look, Spacer… Good policework is finding a balance. Because we're never going to stop everything, and you'll drive yourself crazy trying.

[She starts eating again.]

Jon: (hushed) I just feel like we should be out there. Doing… I don't know. Something.

Crowley: (food in her mouth) Did you sleep last night?

Jon: A couple of hours. Why?

Crowley: What a waste of time! You should've been out there, doing something.

Jon: I get your point.

Crowley: So eat something. Refuel. Think about the information we have, and then we can put all of our efforts into finding… What was the name again?

Jon: Joy.

Crowley: Stupid name. But all these serial killers have inflated egos. I'm not surprised they named themself. (beat) You got that tape?

[Jon pulls it out.]

Jon: Yeah. Here.

[He slides it over the table.]

Jon: Anything else from the other one?

Crowley: I'd tell you if there was.

[A waitress brings over coffee. She stops by the table.]

Waitress: More coffee, Fran?

Crowley: Mmm. Thank you.

Waitress: (to Jon) More coffee?

Jon: Tea. Actually. Could I get some more hot water?

[She walks away. Crowley sips the coffee. Her walkie squawks.]

Dispatch (V.O.): Sheriff Crowley, we've got reports of a potential homicide in the fifteen hundred block near your location.

[She pushes the button on her walkie.]

Crowley: Copy. Send my car the address. On my way in two.

[She takes another quick bite.]

Jon: Am I coming with you?

Crowley: (food in her mouth) Actually, I was going to surprise you, but Grant okay'd you to return to the hospital.

Jon: Seriously?

Crowley: I barely had to push for it. So you head there; I'll swing by with whatever I find.

Jon: How well do you know Grant?

Crowley: Well enough. Why? He on your suspect list, too.

Jon: I just… learned some stuff about him recently.

Crowley: Well you might want to keep that to yourself. At least for now, seeing as he got you a job again. Just… No more yelling at hospital staff.

Jon: It was just at Kim. And you know why…

Crowley: Speaking of — It's been two weeks since Kim left. There hasn't been a purple body in a while. No other communications from our killer, right?

[Jon leans in.]

Jon: Actually, Crowley…

Crowley: I fucking knew it. Do not do this to me again.

Jon: That's not the first time Joy has contacted me.

[Her knife scratches the plate, ear-piercing.]

Crowley: (seething) Excuse me?

Jon: I wanted to tell you last time, but you were so mad, I–

Crowley: I'm mad this time!

[The diner gets a little quieter from her yelling. She clears her throat.]

Crowley: You and I… We need to have a serious conversation. (beat) Later.

[She slides out from the booth.]

Crowley: Congratulations on getting your fucking job back.

[She stands, zipping her jacket.]

Crowley: (with venom) And thanks for paying.

[She walks away. The waitress comes back. She sets down a mug.]

Waitress: Here's your hot water.

INT. HOSPITAL HALLWAY – DAY

[Jon walks briefly down the hospital hallway. He reaches the morgue door and scans his badge.]

[It beeps; he's in. He opens the door, stepping inside.]

INT. PATHOLOGY LAB – NIGHT

Crowley: Took you long enough.

Jon: I had to get my paperwork squared away. Admin wasn't even here this late. What happened at the scene?

Crowley: Three bodies at some fucking mansion near JJ's.

Jon: A Vanderbilt place?

Crowley: Old one. Renovated for parties or something. (beat) I've got your gurneys there. Evidence collected here.

[She pats a bucket of evidence. She goes to leave.]

Jon: That's it? No more info?

Crowley: I need cause of death. You needed me to tell you that?

Jon: You were giving me the details on the scenes before…

Crowley: Maybe we we were being honest with each other.

Jon: I didn't lie to you, Crowley. I was scared. I didn't know what to do.

Crowley: Well keeping it from me wasn't it.

[She sighs.]

Crowley: It was a murder mystery dinner gone wrong.

Jon: What the hell is a murder mystery dinner?

Crowley: Are you kidding? You really do live under a rock.

Jon: That doesn't really explain anything…

Crowley: A group of people go to a dinner and some actors set up a fake murder. The players have to solve the murder by the time the dinner's over. It's like a fun party activity.

Jon: Murder as a fun party activity…

Crowley: It's not real murder. Except in this case. (beat) When the game ended, three of the "dead" actors didn't get up. Someone called 9-1-1 and first responders said the vics were dead for almost an hour by the time they arrived. We've got the rest of the players and the two living actors in to my department for questioning. I need you to help me sort through what is real evidence and what isn't.

Jon: The scene was tainted?

Crowley: We've got trace everywhere. Our main suspect tried CPR on each of them. It sounds to me like an easy way to explain away their DNA all over everything.

White: (transatlantic accent, overacted)

[It wasn't James! I keep trying to tell her…]

Jon: Uh-huh. I hear you… Well… Let me dive in.

[Crowley scoffs.]

Crowley: That's it, huh?

Jon: What do you mean?

Crowley: You know what, Spacer? After what you told me… I can't let you work the Joy case with me any more.

Jon: What?!

Crowley: Not right now. In the event that this goes to trial… I can't risk having you fuck up the case. So your name doesn't appear on any documents. Only you and I know about your involvement, and that's how it's going to stay until we figure out who Joy is, and arrest this son of a bitch. Then you can come in and nail them with whatever evidence you find.

Jon: I know you don't want anything official, but–

Crowley: I'm doing the rest of this alone. That's it. End of discussion. (beat)

Crowley: If you get any more tapes, or have anything else to tell me, you better damn well do it.

Jon: I've got nothing.

Crowley: Good. Then stay in the lab; stay safe; and let me stop Joy on my own. Got it?

Jon: Crowley…

Crowley: Don't fucking sulk. (beat) You asked how we can stop a serial killer if we keep getting distracted by other homicides, right? Well, this is how. You solve the other homicides. I stop the serial killer.

[She slams the lab door. Jon is left alone. He pulls the sheets off the three bodies.]

Mustard: Harsh. No idea what that was about, but… it sounded harsh.

Plum: (posh British) Shut up, Mustard. Your incessant badgering was probably what got us killed in the first place.

Mustard: Yeah, because you killed us.

Plum: I did nothing of the sort!

White: Boys, please. It was clearly Annie that did us in.

Jon: Please stop bickering.

Plum: Wait… You can hear us?

Jon: Yes, I can. Now please shut up so I can figure out what killed you all.

[Jon starts putting on gloves.]

Mustard: Maybe the sheriff wasn't too harsh on him.

White: No, no, no — you need to explain. We tried communicating with everyone else who's been nearby.

Plum: Clearly we're dead, but–

Mustard: We figured that much out ourselves.

Plum: Mustard, I swear to God!

Jon: Your name is Mustard?

[He picks up a chart.]

Mustard: Colonel Mustard. And that obnoxious son of a bitch is Plum.

Plum: A Professor.

White: And I'm Mrs. White.

Mustard: A white person.

White: Shut up, Mustard!

Jon: Why are you all still in character? You can drop the act.

Plum: I am actually a professor.

Jon: With a terrible British accent? The chart says your name is Scott Mills.

Plum: Hmph.

Jon: You guys can drop the act, right? It's not stuck because you're dead?

White: I never break character.

Mustard: I do; fuck that! I'm Austin.

Jon: Nice to meet you, Austin. I'm Jon. I'm a pathologist here to figure out what actually killed you.

White: It was Annie Peacock.

Jon: I'm guessing that's another actor?

Mustard: Yeah. But she didn't kill us; Plum did. He's fucking crazy.

Plum: Say it to my face, sir!

Jon: Jesus Christ, guys. Break it up. Break it up. You can't touch each other anyway. Just… someone tell me what caused all of this blood all over your bodies…

Mustard: Well… It's a little fuzzy.

Jon: What do you mean? None of you remember who killed you?

White: Well…

Jon: I don't see any physical signs that could indicate a cause of death. Your bodies look fine.

Mustard: Thank you.

Jon: I mean like you weren't stabbed, shot or…

Mustard: Hit with a candlestick?

Plum: It's jokes like that which got us targeted for the heinous act.

White: I don't think anyone attacked us.

Jon: Then what's with all the blood?

Mustard: It's fake blood. Just a prop.

[Jon touches it.]

Jon: Interesting… the dried texture is pretty accurate.

Mustard: That's good to know. I'll leave our new blood supplier a 5-star review.

Jon: So, fake blood. Did anyone attack you?

Plum: Not that I know of.

White: I think we were poisoned.

Jon: Poison huh?

White: I remember getting really sleepy, and then having trouble breathing, but… I was so dizzy I just closed my eyes and couldn't get up.

Plum: A similar situation to myself.

Mustard: My chest was hurting.

Jon: Hurting how?

Mustard: Like… burning. Stinging almost. My heart was pounding.

Jon: Hmmm. Maybe something that affected your respiration and blood pressure. There are a handful of things.

White: So how can you tell who killed us?

[Jon slides the metal tray of tools over.]

Jon: Well first I need to narrow down the how before we can get to the who. I'm going to be conducting the autopsy. Starting with your esophagus and diaphragm.

White: (deadpan, normal voice) You're going to cut us open?

Mustard: What happened to never dropping character?

White: (back to transatlantic) Shut up, Austin!

Jon: You all might not want to watch this. It can be a little… off- putting to see yourself be cut open.

Mustard: You know from experience?

Jon: I've been told.

[White and Plum walk further away. No foot sounds, but their audio is more distant.]

White: I'll wait over here.

Plum: I think I'll just have a seat…

Jon: Austin, are you alright being here?

Mustard: I'm ready for it. Anything to put Plum in jail.

Plum: I told you I didn't do this. Why would I kill you and then myself?

[Jon picks up a chart.]

Jon: Alright. Getting started on Austin Greene. (beat) Wait. Your last name is Greene, and you picked Colonel Mustard?

Mustard: I was a last minute cast.

[He puts down the chart, picking up a scalpel instead.]

Jon: Mhm… Beginning incision…

[Jon does surgery during the next part of the conversation, complete with gross bodily fluid sounds and skin peeling.]

Jon: You know, Scott brings up a good point–

Plum: Professor Plum.

Jon: Scott asked why he'd kill himself afterward.

Mustard: Clearly to hide his intent. He wanted revenge on me for stealing Annie.

Plum: You stole no one from me! Annie and I had a mutual understanding.

White: A woman isn't a thing to steal from anyone.

Mustard: Says the girl in the provocative maid's outfit.

White: It's a costume. At least I was good at my role.

Plum: You are always the first one killed.

Jon: Enough. I meant the timeframe question Scott proposed, not the motive.

Mustard: What?

[Jon sighs.]

Jon: What order were you all killed in?

Mustard: In the game? White, me and then Plum.

Jon: Any idea who died first in real life? Walk me through the events of the party.

Plum: It's not a very technically-intense process, doctor.

Plum: We invite people over for dinner, start the game and lie under a sheet.

Mustard: Why don't you want to tell him, Plum? Have something to hide?

Plum: Hmph.

White: The guests arrive at 5:00. We serve cocktails and mingle while they get to know a bit of our back stories. Then, right before dinner is served, Colonel Mustard discovers my dead body in the sitting room.

[Jon slides his stool over to the next victim. He picks up the chart.]

Jon: Moving on to the esophagus examination of… Winnie Marsh. Your name is Winnie?

White: (normal accent) My parents were from the south. Sue me.

Mustard: Didn't see anything in my throat, doc?

[He starts cutting into White's neck.]

Jon: I did, actually. But I wanted to confirm before I said anything.

[Plum comes closer.]

Plum: What is it?

Jon: I'm seeing burning along the sides of Austin's throat. Winnie's now as well.

Mustard: What's that mean?

Jon: It means something caused the burning.

Plum: (dry) Genius. I see why you do this job now.

Jon: What about the food?

White: What do you mean?

Jon: Did you all eat the food at the party? Anything in particular that someone else might not have?

White: We all have dinner together before the guests arrive. Plum cooks.

Plum: Just an additional portion of what we're serving to the guests. Normal ingredients and nothing I'd put in there to kill anyone.

White: Maybe someone else poisoned it.

Jon: I can have Crowley check if anyone else is showing symptoms.

Mustard: Don't bother.

White: Why not?

Mustard: I didn't eat anything for dinner.

Jon: You didn't?

[Jon slides his chair over, starting on the autopsy of Plum.]

Mustard: No. I got food from JJ's earlier in the afternoon. Plum's cooking sucks.

Plum: How dare you!

Mustard: I'm honestly surprised people don't complain after the party.

Plum: You scoundrel!

Jon: Okay, so you didn't eat the same things… But Scott's throat is also showing the same type of burn marks. Is it possible you were injected with something? Anyone feel a pinch or a prick out of the blue?

Plum: I know one prick in here.

Mustard: I don't think so. Winnie?

White: Not that I remember.

[Jon sighs, pushing out the chair.]

Jon: Alright then. I'm moving on to chest cavity examination to look at your lungs.

[He walks over to a drawer and pulls out the bone saw.]

Jon: This definitely won't be pretty.

Mustard: Oh geez; what is that?

Jon: A bone saw, to get through your breastbones.

White: I need some air…

Plum: We don't breathe air. We're dead.

Jon: It's going to be loud, and… crunchy. And I'm going to have to do it three times. So… brace yourselves.

[He turns on the saw.]

Mustard: Oh good; me first!

[He saws through the bone, creating the Y-shape. Mustard and Jon talk over the first one.]

Mustard: (yelling) What are you doing?

Jon: (yelling) We cut in a Y-incision, to pull back the skin and open up the chest cavity… Then we can sew it up afterward. (beat) And… through.

White: Please… Just look at him first and do the rest later.

Jon: Fine. If I can find something…

[He puts the bone saw down on the tray. He slides the stool and starts digging into Mustard's body.]

Jon: Hmmm… The diaphragm seems fine… But your lungs… Wow.

Mustard: Not good?

Jon: Does that look good?

Mustard: Honestly… Can't tell.

Jon: It's not good. Your lungs are perforated. They grew tiny holes in them, until…

Mustard: The holes got bigger and bigger to look like that, huh?

Jon: Exactly. You were probably long dead before the holes reached anywhere near this big. But it must've been very painful.

Plum: Yes, yes, but what does that mean? How did we die?

Jon: I've seen something like this before, but since it was just your lungs, I don't think it's the same… (beat) How did no one discover you?

White: We were under sheets.

Jon: Sheets?

[He takes off his gloves as he walks to the evidence bin.]

Mustard: Once one of us is "killed off" in the game, they put a white sheet over us so we can check our phones, hang out and move without breaking immersion.

[Jon puts on another pair of gloves. He takes off the evidence bin lid.]

Jon: These sheets?

[He pulls sheets out of the evidence bin.]

White: Yes. Those.

[Jon reels back.]

Jon: Phew! That smell.

Mustard: What smell?

Jon: You don't smell that?

Plum: It's ammonia. We're probably nose- blind. We use it ever week.

Jon: Ammonia….

White: It's not ammonia. It's bleach.

Jon: Are you sure?

Plum: Of course it's ammonia. I cleaned them myself.

Mustard: Not very well.

Jon: What do you mean?

Mustard: Plum washed the sheets, but they still had the fake blood on them from the night before. So I asked Winnie to clean them quickly…

White: And I threw them in the wash again right before the guests arrived.

Plum: You did?

[Jon sniffs the sheets.]

Jon: Phew! So you washed the sheets first, Scott? With ammonia.

Plum: Yes. I do it every time. I just apply the ammonia to the blood stains and they come out overnight.

Mustard: Except this is a new product, remember? The ammonia didn't get the stains out.

Jon: So Winnie, you… washed the sheets with bleach?

White: Yeah. Why?

Jon: Do any of you clean your bathrooms at home?

Mustard: Uhhh…

Plum: What does this have to do with our death?

Jon: Well, if you ever read the little label on the back of cleaning supplies, it tells you not to mix any cleaner with another. Do you know why that is? (beat) Because things that contain bleach… and things that contain ammonia, do not work well together when they mix.

[Jon throws the sheets back in the bin. He closes it.]

Jon: I don't even want to smell it now. Let alone with your face under it.

Mustard: What happens when you mix them?

Jon: Bleach and ammonia create mustard gas.

Plum: (finally dropping accent) The stuff they used in World War One?

Jon: Exactly.

White: So we made…

Mustard: Mustard gas.

Jon: A highly corrosive concoction that, when inhaled for even a small amount of time, causes dizziness, drowsiness, and eventually, holes to form in the lungs as the air corrodes them. (beat) You all killed each other.

[There's a long pause.]

Plum: (back in accent) Mystery solved.

Mustard: Well this fucking sucks.

White: And Annie had nothing to do with it…

Mustard: Well, she did kind of have something to do with it. If Plum wasn't so pissed about Annie, he might've paid more attention to the sheets.

Plum: I was not mad about Annie!

Mustard: You sound mad right now.

White: You told me to wash the sheets again!

Mustard: I didn't tell you to use bleach!

[Jon takes off his gloves, walking away.]

Jon: I'm just going to… give you all… a minute…

White: You didn't tell me not to use bleach.

Plum: Both of you idiots killed me!

[Jon goes into the office, shutting the door. The arguing continues, but muffled.]

INT. MORGUE OFFICE – NIGHT

[A wall clock ticks as Jon picks up the phone. He dials Crowley's cell. In the background.]

White: You should've told me you used ammonia. Who uses ammonia?!

Plum: Who doesn't know what mustard gas is?!

Mustard: You only know because you're a fucking weirdo who's probably tried to poison people on multiple occasions.

Plum: I hate you, Mustard.

Mustard: My name is Austin! I don't ever want to hear the name Mustard again.

White: They never should've hired you in the first place. You're a terrible actor.

Mustard: (mimicking her accent) You're a terrible actor, mehhh! With your fake transatlantic accent. We're set in the 1700's, Winnie! That accent wasn't invented yet.

Jon: Hey, Crowley… It's Jon. I've identified the source of the smell on the sheets as toxic levels of bleach and ammonia. Their lungs confirm the cause of death. Check the stories with who washed them, and we'll probably have the verdict. Thanks.

[He hangs up.]

Join the discussion

Categories

Episode 45