How i Died S2 E12: Broken

Play episode

A pleasant chat in mandatory therapy. 

How i Died is an Audiohm Media original, starring Vince Dajani as Jon Spacer; Shaina Waring as Sheriff Fran Crowley; David Dixon as Curtis; Caitlin Roberts as Amelia; Vyn Vox as Dr. Kim. Guest starring Chris Harris-Beechey as the receptionist.

Support the show and get bonus content at https://Patreon.com/HowiDied

Written and created by Vince Dajani. Directing and sound design by Vince Dajani and Chroma Sikora. Mastering by Eric Howell.

The How I Died theme song was created by Mike Lynch at SilentMikeMusic.com.

Show notes and transcript available at https://audiohmmedia.com/howidied/

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Transcript: How i Died S2 E12: Broken

This transcript is adapted from the episode’s original script, so the final audio may differ slightly.

[Intro The clock ticks softly. People fidget]

PhD: You’re awfully quiet today.

Jon: I have a lot on my mind.

PhD: Anything you care to share?

Jon: No.

PhD: Are you feeling okay?

Jon: Are you? You don’t look so great.

PhD: I’m coming down with something.

Jon: Take a sick day.

PhD: I’m not that sick.

Jon: Take a sick day anyway. Let’s just both head out now.

PhD: Very funny, Jonathan.

Jon: It’s flu season.

PhD: Have you spoken with Amelia recently?

Jon: No.

PhD: Are you okay with that?

Jon: Why wouldn’t I be?

PhD: She was someone close to you.

Jon: And now she’s not.

PhD: And how has that affected you?

Jon: It hasn’t.

PhD: Have you cried?

Jon: How can I answer that? If I have cried, it’s effected me and you’ll want to talk about it. If I haven’t cried, I’m not dealing with it, and you’ll want to talk to me about it. Which answer gets us to move on?

PhD: It’s something we should talk about.

Jon: Fine. No, I haven’t cried because I’m not upset. I’m not avoiding dealing with emotions – there just aren’t any to deal with.

PhD: So she didn’t mean anything to you.

Jon: I don’t know what she meant.

PhD: Did she make you happy?

Jon: She was a distraction.

PhD: Distraction from what?

Jon: When she and I started seeing each other, it was right after I’d screwed up a case.

PhD: So you sought some comfort in another person after you made a mistake. Interesting.

Jon: Don’t say that.

PhD: Say what?

Jon: "Interesting" like that. I know it just means you want to say something, so say it.

PhD: Which case was it?

Jon: A few months ago, a farmer was killed.

PhD: Ah, yes. Sherrif Fran gave me copies of the closed case files. She suspected it was an accident, which is was. I’m guessing you suspected… Murder? (Pause) That’s what I thought. You see foul play in everything, don’t you? Why do you think that is?

Jon: Because there is always foul play.

PhD: Just not in that case.

Jon: Not in that one, no.

PhD: You’re from Baltimore, correct? I’d imagine foul play is pretty common with deaths in the city.

Jon: It’s just different.

PhD: So you were wrong. It didn’t impact the case’s outcome. Why were you so upset?

Jon: I don’t like to be wrong.

PhD: Does it happen so infrequently?

Jon: …No.

PhD: So why this one specifically? What was the significance for you?

Jon: I don’t know.

PhD: Could it be that the last body part you found left a case open, and you were trying to redeem yourself?

Jon: I thought Crowley only gave you the closed case files.

PhD: Everyone’s heard about Stephen Maur. That was the talk of the town for months. Until your incident.

Jon: We never found his body. I couldn’t do anything else on that case.

PhD: Fine, fine. We’ll move on. If Amelia didn’t make you feel better after your initial mistake, then what did?

Jon: Nothing. I was wrong about the case, but figured something else out about another.

PhD: About the purple bodies?

Jo: Yes.

PhD: What’s making you so obsessed with those cases?

Jon: There’s a mystery. Something that someone has gotten away with for years, and I’ve discovered it. I’m going to find out who’s behind it.

PhD: Even though Sheriff Fran had repeatedly said that there wasn’t a case there?

Jon: She believes me now.

PhD: Does she? Very intertesting.

Jon: There’s that word again.

PhD: Other than solving cases, what makes you happy?

Jon: Proving people wrong.

PhD: Surely there’s something else in your life. You should find something outside of your work that brings you joy

Jon: Joy?

PhD: Yes. True bliss, happiness, a feeling of freedom from anxieties. Joy.

Jon: I don’t know.

PhD: I’d like to bring up a topic that I think will be difficult for you.

Jon: As opposed to the ease of the rest of our meetings?

PhD: Medication.

Jon: I’m not on any medication. I stopped taking ibuprofen weeks ago.

PhD: I’m talking about medication you’re not on. I’d like to suggest trying a low dose anti-anxiety perscription.

Jon: No thanks.

PhD: You won’t be a zombie or anything. These would be the right mixture for your body, just to reduce the amount of stress and negative emotion you place on yourself.

Jon: I’m well aware of how they work.

PhD: Ah, yes. You were on Fluoxetine for quite some time in your past, right? Ages… Fourteen to eighteen?

Jon: And then Emsam, for panic disorder.

PhD: And then?

Jon: And then I stopped.

PhD: Were they ineffective? (Coughs) Excuse me.

Jon: They weren’t treating the right problem.

PhD: What was the right problem to treat?

Jon: I don’t know.

PhD: But you do know they weren’t treating it?

Jon: My therapist back then just wanted to numb me out.

PhD: Of a past trauma?

Jon: Do you have something you want to ask me?

PhD: Do you have something you wanted to tell?

Jon: Depends what you got out of my patient file.

PhD: We don’t need to discuss-

Jon: We do need to discuss it. Either you know the whole story, or you don’t.

PhD: I’d like to hear it from you.

Jon: Give me a hint.

PhD: Fine. I received your medical history paperwork, but nothing else. No notes from any previous therapists.

Jon: So that means you’re inferring that I experienced some trauma based on my previous medications.

PhD: And on your recent actions here. It doesn’t take much to pick up on queues when you get anxious. Did you experience some trauma?

Jon: I’m sure you did your research. That part is public.

PhD: I did… But I want to hear it from you.

Jon: Which is not going to happen.

PhD: Why not? It’s important for me to know how you interpret what you went through.

Jon: I interpreted it as a terrible situation for a kid to experience. That’s it.

PhD: And that’s how you’ve dealt with this?

Jon: I get it. I’m broken.

PhD: I didn’t say that.

Jon: It’s been implied since our first session. Since Crowley mandated it.

PhD: Therapy isn’t about fixing what’s broken. It’s about growing and healing.

Jon: Okay. Healing what’s broken.

PhD: (resolved) Have you been working on how you react to people, like we discussed?

Jon: Yes. Can’t you tell?

PhD: You were showing improvement. What’s changed?

Jon: I learned something new.

PhD: Care to share?

Jon: No.

[Water pouring]

PhD: My throat is bothering me. Would you like something to drink?

Jon: I’m fine.

PhD: I learned a lot of new things too, by the way.

[Phd gets up and plays the recording.]

PhD: Can I play something for you?

Jon: Can I say no?

PhD: Heh. I’m going to play it anyway. Let’s take a listen. (Pause) I’m sure you’ll recognize it.

[Recording from jon and curtis plays a bit in the background.]

Jon: Why are you playing this?

PhD: Because we need to talk about this day, Jonathan. We’ve been dancing around it.

Jon: Well, let’s keep dancing.

PhD: You dropped off this tape purposefully.

Jon: Uhhh…

PhD: So you must have wanted to talk about it, right?

Jon: No… I thought it might just be what you wanted to hear.

PhD: Why is that?

Jon: Why did I think you wanted to hear it, or why did I drop it off?

PhD: Both.

Jon: I… Dropped it off because I thought hearing how the actual situation with Curtis went down might change your opinion of me…

PhD: Why?

Jon: What do you mean why? I’m afraid in this recording. I’m trying to live. It’s like watching a video of a mugging.

PhD: Did you share it with Sheriff Fran?

Jon: No. But I didn’t know I had it. I wasn’t even aware the microphone was on during it.

PhD: So you discovered evidence to help clear your name, according to you, but then you decided to not share it with the police, but rather with me first.

Jon: Uhh… You are the one clearing my name.

PhD: To work. Not legally. Your case is still open, correct?

Jon: Technically.

PhD: I’m going to have to share this with Fran.

Jon: That’s fine.

PhD: It’s okay to be upset while listening to this. I’m sure it’s hard to hear.

[Clip continues to play]

PhD: Have you had any anxiety from going down in the lab?

Jon: No.

PhD: No increase in heart rate when you open the door, or dread about coming in to work?

Jon: No.

PhD: That’s good.

Jon: Fantastic. So why does it sound like you don’t believe me.

PhD: Because whether you want to admit it or not, this was a trauamatic event. And trauma effects us.

Jon: Do you have any tissues? I’m going to tear up.

PhD: I do. But I don’t like to give them to my patients unless they really need them.

Jon: I thought handing over tissues was exactly what therapists did.

PhD: No. That’s something you only see on TV. Real counselors know that by handing you a tissue when you start to cry, I’m essentially saying you should clean that up, and stop. And that’s the opposite of what we want.

Jon: I wasn’t really asking.

PhD: I know. (Pause) Can you tell me about this bit?

Jon: What "bit"?

PhD: Here. (Recorded section of John tricking Curtis)

Jon: He was paranoid and delusional.

PhD: And he thought the dead woman was-

Jon: Becca.

PhD: Right. Is that a sensitive area for you? The naming of the victims.

Jon: It is now. It’s her name.

PhD: You mean, was, her name, right? (Pause) You tricked Curtis perfectly here. You said Becca was still alive in the room.

Jon: I was feeding into his delusion. Like a hostage who plays along with the captor.

PhD: It was quick thinking.

Jon: It was what saved me.

PhD: And gave you the chance to strike.

Jon: Like I said… It was what saved me.

PhD: On which stab were you safe? The first. The second… The eighth? Do you want to listen?

Jon: No.

[Stabbing section plays]

PhD: Do you regret what you did?

Jon: If I say yes, can I go back to work?

PhD: Most likely. If we continue working on your anger.

Jon: I don’t…

PhD: Why not?

Jon: Because.

PhD: Please go on. (Pause) I’m trying to help you, Jonathan.

Jon: I’ve heard that before.

PhD: Well you haven’t heard it from me.

Jon: I feel like I should have.

PhD: You know what I mean. Please continue. Why do you not regret what happened?

Jon: I didn’t say I didn’t regret what happened. I said I’m not sure if I regret what *I* did. I defended myself. I saved myself in a moment of fear.

PhD: And you killed someone.

Jon: I had to.

PhD: Did you think stabbing him was necessary?

Jon: I& I think so.

PhD: How about stabbing him nine times? Was that neccesary to survive? (Pause) Let me ask another way: you don’t regret what you did. Do you think you could have handled it differently. How it played out?

Jon: I’m not going to live in what ifs. Next time you’re face to face with a person with a gun pointed at you, let’s see how well you can talk them off a bridge.

[Crowley saves jon on the recording]

PhD: Were you aware that Sheriff Fran was the one who saved you?

Jon: Not until recently.

PhD: Has that changed your relationship at all? You mentioned she believes you about the purple bodies.

Jon: That’s because there’s actually a killer.

PhD: Or she now feels closer to you and wants to help.

Jon: She signed me up for these damn sessions.

PhD: Because the other option was to fire you outright and keep you unemployed in Springfield until your court date. You should consider this a favor.

Jon: Great. Now I owe her two…

PhD: Have you noticed that you’re more cordial with her as well?

Jon: Yeah, but that’s because she…

PhD: Have you been having trouble sleeping?

Jon: I barely slept before.

PhD: Does that mean you’re not sleeping now? (Long pause) Jonathan, anxiety and Guilt are all normal emotional responses. (Sighing) Fine. We can try something else. How were you sleep habits and stress levels after your father killed your mother.

Jon: Fucking wowwwww. Is this how therapy is supposed to be helpful? You’re saying that what I did was a byproduct of experiencing a death as a child?

PhD: You seem so nonchalant about this one, that I can only assume that you deem your mother’s death equally inconsequential.

Jon: She was NOT inconsequential.

PhD: There you go. Let it out. Do you want to yell at me?

Jon: Yes.

PhD: What’s stopping you?

Jon: A favor.

[Another glass of water is poured.]

PhD: Anything to drink now?

Jon: Still fine.

PhD: (finishing up the water) Ahh. (Pause) Did you see your father kill your mother?

Jon: (long pause, through gritted teeth) No.

PhD: Did you see anything else?

Jon: What else would there be to see?

PhD: You tell me, Jonathan.

[Long pause. Clock ticking.]

Jon: I walked in on them. He was roughing her up, but I didn’t get the sense that he would…

PhD: Kill her?

Jon: Yes.

PhD: Do you blame yourself?

Jon: Why would I blame myself?

PhD: No reason.

Jon: You’re asking for a reason.

PhD: Fine. You said your father didn’t look homicidal at the time. So to me, that means that somewhere deep down, you think your interaction with them prior to your mother’s death may have been the catalyst for increasing your father’s rage.

Jon: Gee. You got all of that out of a single comment?

PhD: Just like you glean information from a particulate, and Fran finds an inconsistency in a perpetrator’s alibi.

Jon: So now you’re a detective for emotional baggage? I’m sure Crowley would love the metaphor.

PhD: Jokes aside, you can’t blame yourself for what happened.

Jon: I don’t.

PhD: You saw physical abuse as a child.

Jon: And experienced it after she died.

PhD: So then you’ve got to see how that’s affected your personal relationships. With Amelia, with Fran, and even with… The dead.

Jon: What? What do you mean?

PhD: I’m referring to Curtis. But also to your profession.

Jon: Oh…

PhD: You killed someone, and refuse to let it affect you. Your mother died, and you refuse to admit it affected you. You chose forensic pathology as a profession. You chose to surround yourself with death. Even if you’d always wanted to become a doctor, there were plenty of specialties where you could have helped people, prevented death, made people happy.

Jon: Like psychology?

PhD: Why did you choose to stick yourself in a dark lab, working with the dead. What made you do that

Jon: I don’t know.

PhD: Finish this sentence. I choose pathology because I…

Jon: What do you want me to say?

PhD: Do you feel like you deserve to work alone in the dark? Is a lab the only place you feel you’re worth?

Jon: Are you saying pathologists are undervalued, because if I do end up getting approved to stay, I’d be up for a raise.

PhD: Are you chasing after ghosts here, trying to find the answer of your mother’s death, through solving others?

Jon: Is this really supposed to work? You just pose one theory after another at me until, I, what? Snap and tell you the truth, or run out of witty comments?

PhD: There doesn’t seem to be a chance of that last one.

Jon: Yeah. Not likely.

PhD: I’m trying to find meaning in your life, Jonathan. Meaning that I’m sure you know, but would be helpful for you to hear.

Jon: I know my meaning.

PhD: Then what is it?

Jon: If I already know it, then why does it matter to you?

PhD: Because I need you to express it. You’ve got rage inside you. You’ve got sadness and shame. And you’re only expressing one of those.

Jon: I don’t-

PhD: Your meaning is to make a difference. To solve crime to prevent future ones. Am I right? (Pause) That’s what I was trying to get you to say. You need to say it aloud. You need to acknowledge your current position. Because you’ve failed, Jonathan. YOU failed in your mission by killing someone. And that hurts you. So you lash out. …But it’s okay. You need to realize that failing is okay.

[Knock at the door]

Receptionist: Doctor Kim. Can I talk to you for a second?

PhD: Is it urgent? We’re in the middle of-

Receptionist: I wouldn’t be interrupting if it wasn’t.

PhD: Okay. (Pause) Sure. Um. Jonathan, give me a minute?

Receptionist: Maybe five to ten…

PhD: Don’t leave. Regardless of how much it seems like the perfect opportunity.

[Door closes]

Jon: Pfft. I had a different opportunity in mind.

[Movement, shuffling, Jon is searching for something. He starts thumbing through a file.]

Jon: You had to have notes from your time at Springfield… Where are they? I know they’re not going to be digitalized. Fucking sketchy fucks didn’t want any way for their work to be tracked. Damnit. There’s a locked safe. That’s probably where they are. Hmmm… Wow. A medication cabinet in the office? That’s odd. Lots of medications… Chemo bags and pill bottles… There are some old patient files in the cabinet here. Wow… Very old. I see Ray and Mike Melba… Alex Mendez… That could be interesting. Nothing on the Bubble or the actual project at Springfield. Just a bunch of – wait. Roger Benhoff? That’s R.B. the pathologist before me… (Reading). Distrusting… Self-destructive tendencies… Benhoff showed hesitation toward doing what needed to be done. Reluctancy to sign off paperwork and increasing feelings of anciety and guilt. Perscribed anti-depressants What the fuck… There’s a note attached: "Stop the leak." Underlined. There’s an obituary under, titled Roger Benhoff’s "suicide"… in air quotes.

[Door opens]

Receptionist: What are you doing?

Jon: Is Kim coming back?

Receptionist: Is that a patient file?

Jon: How long have you known her?

Receptionist: You need to leave. Doctor Kim is stuck with a patient in the psych wing, and they won’t be back before the end of your session.

Jon: Of course they won’t. Can’t have any more whistle blowers in the psych wing.

Receptionist: Excuse me?

Jon: Nothing. Tell Kim I’ll be back.

Join the discussion

Categories

Episode 33